Print Recipe

Harry Potter Sorting Hat Cookies

These sorting hat cookies are a perfect party piece. Each cookie is filled with a different color of M&Ms. The kids each pick their cookie and then break it open to find out which house they are in!
Course: Dessert
Keyword: cookies, Food, Harry Potter, Recipe


  • Chocolate Cookies I made cake mix cookies using a chocolate cake mix
  • Sugar Cones
  • Chocolate Candy Rolls
  • Mutil-Colored Candy
  • Melting Chocolate or Chocolate Frosting


  • First separate your color candies into four different piles. Blue for Ravenclaw, green for Slytherin, yellow for Hufflepuff and red for Gryffindor.
  • Work the chocolate candy rolls with your hands until they are soft and you are able to mold them. Each Sorting Hat face took about three chocolate rolls. Two for the eyebrow line and one for the mouth line. You aren’t working to an exact science, just working to give it a little bit of a face. You can find Sorting Hat pictures here, to get a better idea of what you are working towards.
  • Once your face is on your ice cream cone, fill your cone with one color of candy and then dip the bottom of your cone in either melted chocolate or frosting to secure it to the brim of the hat, or the chocolate cookie. I used just a little bit of melted chocolate, I felt like it was cleaner. After your Sorting Hat is secured, you are ready to be sorted. Have each person randomly grab a hat and discover what house they are in!